Looking back over business history we can see that management consultants have influenced institutional thinking, the language of business, and, above all, the re-organization of people’s lives.
The leading gurus of management became famous because of their academic accomplishments, books they’d authored, new business insights they’d created and political influence gained with industry leaders. The gurus’ play book fed the appetite of a business ego-system obsessed with short-term results to satisfy Wall Street, stockholders and self-serving management agenda’s. Employees always knew a layoff was imminent whenever management announces a new initiative (re-engineering, reorganization, and quality improvement), being implemented by yet another management consulting firm.
New initiatives, or this year’s management de jour, show management trying to come to grips with radical changes yet recognizing they do not have the knowledge necessary to find adequate solutions. So what has management traditionally done? Hire in the knowledge gurus, management consultants.
How Much Does It Cost to Get Knowledge?
Companies pay executives to manage the business. Managing a business requires knowledge. Management’s job is not only to have the right kind of knowledge to do the job but to continually acquire new knowledge necessary to manage the changing dynamics. The problem is management doesn’t have time to acquire new knowledge so the easy thing to do is hire someone else who has it. The reason they don’t have time is because their time becomes tied up solving old problems. I guess the old knowledge was inadequate.
Management consulting has been and still is an industry that capitalizes on the study of macroeconomic, technological and social change then creating labels for new management theories they’ve discovered from their infinite wisdom. Also known as factories of new knowledge for sale, you can only get the knowledge from their books, their anointed apostles who’ve been trained in the practices or you can get it from a copycat at cheaper prices.
Ira Sager writes in a June 13, 2013 Bloomberg BusinessWeek article: Over the next 12 months, 82 percent of the U.S. clients surveyed by market researcher Source Information Services say they won’t cut the amount they spend on outside help. And nearly half, 42 percent, plan to bring in even more consultants, while 5 percent expect to boost their spending on consultants by more than 50 percent.
The U.S. market for management consulting grew 8.5 percent last year, to $39.3 billion. The fastest-growing areas: marketing and sales (25.6 percent), operational improvement (11.3 percent), and technology (10.1 percent).
Where do U.S. companies need help? Not surprisingly, digitization is high on the list, which the research firm says is benefiting consulting companies IBM (IBM), Deloitte, and Accenture (ACN), leaders in this area. “Where the rest of the world talks about globalization, America talks about digitization,” according to the report.
U.S. companies, however, are spending much less on strategy consulting. That sector is expected to grow just 3.7 percent next year, not good news for McKinsey, Bain, and other leading strategy specialists.
Management consulting has been and still is a huge business because, understanding and applying new knowledge is the solution to every business problem. This is especially true when markets are undergoing dramatic changes.
The Business of Knowledge is Being Transformed
The word “consult” means to ask advice or opinion of or to deliberate together. We are living in a knowledge driven economy that is
heavily influenced by collaborative forces sharing intangible and tangible assets to create new value. The internet has accelerated collaboration and people are learning from the interactions.
Note the Bloomberg BusinessWeek article states that the fastest growing areas companies are seeking help in are marketing and sales, operational improvements and not surprisingly digitization. So the obvious question that one might ask is whether the answers to these issues exist within the organizations “social network” and “resources of knowledge” or does it only exist in the minds of expensive management consultants?
The internet will be disrupting the management consulting industry’s business and mental models because more and more people are seeking wisdom while many consulting firms are still trying to sell knowledge. Knowledge has become a commodity because of digitization. Wisdom comes from transforming knowledge into a skill that changes your results. Now there are tools to help the transformation.
We’ll look at these issue further in Part II through Part IV next.

{ 50 comments }
Next Comments →
it is very good article and is giving a lot of information such as some Nations looking at Globalization and whilst America forecasting on Digitalization.
Great article. I believe that management consultant is to bring change or improvement to their clients. If MC can’t handle disruption in own industry than it is too bad for these MCs. The great and creative ones will definitely excel through this disruption.
i’am waiting Part 2.
FOR THE MODERATOR TO PASS ALONG TO THE POWERS THAT BE:
Although I find your articles to be generally interesting and stimulating, I am put off by the poor quality of the editing (or the lack thereof). The second paragraph of this piece is typical. Plurals in English do not take apostrophes, and the word you want is “imminent”, not “eminent”. Errors of this nature are prevalent in every article I’ve read on this site, and IMHO you need to address this sooner rather than later.
I really liked the article, as it explain very well why Mgt consultants are needed to bring about improvements. I am mgt consultant from operation improvement area, implementation based consulting.
In my humble submission there are 3 other ways in which management consultants add value in organisation, besides the knowledge.
1. Having someone dedicated to think of specific business challenges while being perfectly aligned to deliver results on the case, helps.
2. Bringing in fresh perspective by sheer virtue of bringing in an outsider and not necessarily the smartest person around, helps.
3. Being able to recommend and strengthen what is best for the business without being influenced by internal personal dynamics, helps.
Although knowledge is a barrier which can be overcome but others are a bit difficult to achieve as long as one is an internal stakeholder
Jay, thanks a lot! Interesting perspective on the evolution of the role and adequacy of the management consulting industry and practice. My opinion is that today, in the era of the ubiquitous Internet and easier access to basic knowledge, the management consulting practice has to be moving towards mentoring. Mentorship may be a significant source for the business growth through delivering expertise and various perspectives. The role of a mentor is not limited only by a sharing of experience and helping out to draft a roadmap for the business growth. At the same time the mentor is playing a role of a coach, thus, he does not just deliver a “wisdom” but teaches entrepreneurs to generate well-grounded and creative strategies and decisions. That role is very much essential for the tech entrepreneurs who in a major part have technical background and are thinking “technically” instead of thinking “businessly” (sorry for using the neologisms). Thanks!
Good article , I’m waiting part 2.
Not putting tomatoes into fruit salad shows a lack of willingness to explore options and adherence to preconceptions. The ability to deal with both these factors is a key characteristic of the best, and thus most useful of management consultants. Management consultants should be the jester at the court of the great mediaeval king, or the slave hired to whisper in the ear the emperor, “Remember Caesar, you too are mortal”. Beware the delusions of wisdom and knowledge.
It seems to me that a management team can still have a hard time searching for good and suitable information. How this information can become on knowledge and even better become in wisdom is a process that incorporate too many elements to produce a high performance output in a short time period. That is the uniqueness that management consultants still are exploting and thus very hard to acquire or transfer by simply surfing the internet.
You’ve got to love the different perspectives in these comments. Thanks for contributing to the dialog. Disruption doesn’t always mean displacement but it does mean significant change. I hope the rest of the series adds value to these thoughts. More later..
I have had the experience of working for two of the big 5 management consulting firms over the course of 13 years in some of the most complex customer organizations. There is no shortage of expertise, knowledge or use of technology to implement new and improved business processes…the challenge and will likely always be the human element and resistance to change…no matter how proven the new way of business may be. While the executives need to manage the business and keep their eye on the ball, management consultants will always have the challenge of middle management and the base organization that are not vested in the reason for or benefits of doing business more efficiently. The change management element of the transformation typically does not get the prioritization to ensure success because it is the least quantifiable and the most anecdotal of consulting processes. Digitalization is good, maybe people will become more self educated and open to the multi-organizational and multi-industry exposure and experience management consulting can bring to accelerate the transformation process…the idea is a faster ROI on consulting services. Retired and doing my own thing now…applying all this MC knowledge to my own business now.
Excellent Article! Thank you, Jay!
The key point of the article (Part I) is the differentiation between “knowledge” and “wisdom” and transformation of one into the other.
As defined by American Heritage Dictionary, knowledge is
1. The ability to discern or judge what is true, right, or lasting; insight.
2. Common sense; good judgment: “It is a characteristic of wisdom not to do desperate things” (Henry David Thoreau).
Wisdom is largely attained through personal experiences and experiences of others. While knowledge indeed has become a commodity because of digitalization, rapidly growing volume of data is such that it takes considerable effort and time to digest it and identify patterns, correlations, and otherwise turn it into information and actionable business decisions. This is where a combination of tools that automate the analysis and information presentation process (e.g. geospatial analytics) and experience, i..e. ability to apply the lessons of the past to the present, make a huge difference.
Looking forward to reading Part II and beyond…
There are some interesting opinions in this article, that are worthy of some thought, although I can’t say that I agree with all of them, or the author’s conclusion.
If I am not mistaken, the author main proposition is that the MC business is being disrupted due to the availability of ‘knowledge’ (or does he mean information) through the internet. I would have appreciated a more detailed definition and description, of the authors view of what Information, knowledge and wisdom is, and how he believes it is most effectively transferred. another interesting questions is; who is making the knowledge available of the internet? Could it be the very MC industry itself?
I am also more than a little skeptical of how much of that information that is available is really knowledge. I do agree that the internet is allowing clients and customers to become much better informed, upfront, about a myriad of different aspects. However this is happening in all industries and not just MC. What I am not sure about is; why should any consult have a reason to be fearful of a better informed client? Isn’t a better informed client an advantage? But information is not knowledge, and knowledge is not skill, and skill is not yet habit.
Granted, the MC industry will also have to continue to develop and evolve, but I believe consulting will continue to have it’s place in helping businesses better prepare for, and navigate change and difficult situations, where the client is lacking either experience, expertise or possible both. The statistics that are quoted, appear to affirm my belief.
I wish everyone a successful day.
Jack, check out this analysis of information. Going forward one will make good money on providing wisdom and not just knowledge. In the Digital age information is free. But the wisdom on how to maximize to free knowledge is the value that one can bring to the current business world.
It is not about knowing the principles. It is about applying these principles into the business you are supporting. This needs experience and learning from previous applications which may have hit or missed, in varying degrees.
Cheers, Simon
Very nice article and I, too, am looking forward to reading Part 2. I hope some part of this series covers where demand is going for the “executive development” sector of consulting. (I guess common nomenclature would call this “coaching”, although I think that is a highly limiting description.)
I agree with Devils Advocate’s comments. It is a good business strategy to have, to bring in people who specialise in managing organisation change. The key word there is specialise because it is an art and while Managers are busy managing their business to achieve revenue, we MCs are supporting them with provision of specialisation through deep data collection, deep analysis, detailed implementation that considers all aspects of cause and effect relating to each transformation with supporting tools, approach, etc etc… you get the idea. If Managers were doing the consulting work we do, then who would be managing the business? Its an insult to highly productive managers growing business and the MCs helping them to remove waste, be more productive, coach the team etc !
Interesting article. While outsourcing for knowledge to compete meeting goals is all about the bottom line which is met by creative accounting. The two, management and accounting, are, more often than not, conflicting concepts in business. As manager in corporate America wisdom does not apply, quick fixes do, and throwing money at problems is the primary object. Corporate America has hit its ceiling and business needs a new business other than the hierarchy, military style that creates more problems than it can solve.
Contrary to the positive dynamic in the [ data > information > knowledge > wisdom ] paradigm, many organizations seem to buy into the dark side by adopting a [ data > information > stupidity management ] paradigm. A great article on this can be found here >>
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1467-6486.2012.01072.x/abstract
no doubt creating niche and converting knowledge into products will enable boutique firm to grow faster than average
It seems to me the argumentation of this is oversimplified. The added value of top notch consultants (and not just management consultants) is how to TRANSLATE the KNOWLEDGE phase to the WISDOM phase.
Great read Jay. I would love to hear your thoughts on how digitization will disrupt the management consulting space itself? How do you see consultants adapting in the way they win more new business and increase lifetime earnings?
Great read Jay. I would love to hear you thoughts on how digitization will disrupt the management consulting space itself? How do you see consultants adapting in the way they win more new business and increase lifetime earnings?
Very Nice article !!!
Great article on MC. Awaiting part 2!
Management consultants are agents for change and transformation. Too often organisations are paralysed by the politics that prevents progress through internal means. It is often more palatable to deliver difficult messages when via an external source. After who could argue with the conclusions of a top 5 consulting firm?
Management consultants will never be disrupted if they are agile. It all boils down to application of wisdom which is not always possible if you merely conduct desktop research on the Internet.
It’s a very interesting article which pinpoints the trends (?) in management consulting industry. However I assume that the distance from the wisdom is still remains long. Why is that? The existing way of management in Multinational especially corporations guarantees that management consulting services will still be a key of knowledge and wisdom source within firm. The fast growing trend of enterprises to keep the core business skills and outsource the others creates a leakage of business knowledge , which creates an increasing need of business consulting. The only key issue that could be changed is the format of the contribution of business consultants as well as their new profile required to respond to the new technology and operational advances.
Good article. The steps I have used are: data, information, knowledge. And requested my clients to base the actions and decissions on knowledge. Good to get a further logical step called wisdom in the ladder.
Gonna play devil’s advocate:
1) McK and BCG continue to grow at 10+% a year–sounds “healthy” to me
2) All the top firms have long ago since expanded beyond strategy consulting to operations, implementation, etc.–believe me, they know better than anyone that strategy consulting is growing slowly and they have long since positioned themselves into the future
3) Human capital: top MC firms are untouchable when it comes to human capital; this remains true today and no corporation will ever be able to appeal to the cream of the crop from top MBA, PhD, MD, BA programs–no top talent wants to work in a cube with an mind boggling bureaucracy over their heads– for them: they either want to call the shots from the top of that bureaucracy or be a consultant
4) Consultants continue to create new knowledge that creates real value, otherwise companies wouldn’t keep hiring them. Because of the secret nature of MC, the average person underestimates how much impact MC firms have. They might praise a company for an innovative move, but never realize that McK came up with it.
5) If the internet hasn’t disrupted MC by now, it never will. The internet isn’t some new technology… it’s been around for decades. Business problems cannot be solved by the mere existence of a database of best practices/past knowledge/etc. In a competitive landscape, companies cannot afford to sit around for months to act. They need solutions with quick turnaround and will never be able to assemble internally a team willing to put in 16-hour days to complete 6 months of work in 10 weeks. Top consulting firms have no trouble finding those people.
The only reason we claim “management consulting” as our industry is because “digital/mobile” consulting doesn’t exist on a drop down box and neither does strategic collaboration.
Wonderful article! ,The consulting experts have lots of stale knowledge and market trends are changing. People are busy converting the knowledge to wisdom by interaction on the Internet. There is a lot of transformation going on and the Internet is a weapon of global change”.Wisdom comes from transforming knowledge into a skill that changes your results. Now there are tools to facilitate the transformation.” Interactions on the Internet is that essential tool. Sooner than later, the business of consulting for firms will be obsolete.
knowledge is basis, which plus experience produces wisdom. Althought consultants use old knowledge deal with case ,their experience is updated everyday
I provided Mgmt Consulting Svcs to several very large corporations over a period of several years. I helped them reduce inventory, increase manufacturing efficiency, and reduce waste. However, I have witnessed competing consultant firms, focus on their own revenue. I am happy to be retired from the morass!
I truly don’t mean to be catty, but I’m surprised the author didn’t use a copy editor–one form of consultant–before posting this to catch all of the grammatical errors, mixed tenses, and passive voice, thus detracting from his insights–and by extension–his credibility.
On risky projects – forget knowledge. Consulting will be needed for their liability insurance alone.
Director can always point at a consultant to save his own job if the project goes down hill.
Its worth it for them to pay $1k/hr of company’s(!) money to have that excuse.
And if by chance there is actual knowledge applied and project was delivered successfully – its a bonus.
I mean lets not forget that a lot of consultant are a joke.
Can’t wait for the complete article… Tq for the insights.
I wonder that as the Internet makes knowledge and wisdom more accessible the losers maybe bigger consultancies to the benefit o the nimble focused and niche consultants – which also become more accessible
The time of being a knowledge-giver has passed, the future lies with those who can facilitate discernment (wisdom). Consultants will need to be able to coach (rather than teach) their clients to be successful. Or as the article says: “transforming knowledge into a skill that changes your results”.
Predicted in 2006 that consulting would change to co-management based on data and KPI’s. Thanks for sharing.
I am “disturbed”.
I am writing to give another perspective to management consulting role in entities operating in growth areas. While digitization is the trending option for global multinational?entities in growth region would love to see it as something more than just an information system ?IS?strategies though. IS strategies should be devised with insight knowledge of the old knowledge prevailing in any particular organization. Hence?old knowledge shall be the platform to achieve success in knowledge economy. Then?management consultants would be a celebrated problem for these entities
yes, good kick-off of the series, and very interested to read up more, and learn of the comments of the others
The winds are coming! Those of us in the small practice world have seen them coming for a while and have been changing but probably not fast enough! However, we have learned to create shared PMOs rather than simply staffing it with consultants, we are sharing new technologies on discovery rather than after we test them on the client’s ticket, we have learned to work with key staff on troubled projects rather than being the angels of doom and the architects of triumph, we learned from our counterparts in PR that our role is behind the camera and not in front of it and we have embraced new media and the worlds of shareware, mass courses and free services to recognize that our costs though reasonable to us maybe completely unjustified to a client who may be able to get more input on social media networks or high speed trading from a new college graduate than a bunch of 40-50 year olds dragging up what is now the obvious.
Time marches on, one answer is that we have to co-execute more projects and take direct responsibility for failures something that we hardly do now. We also have acknowledge that some of our projects coud be served by internal actors if we gave them a stage and withdrew.
I look forward to the next installment since we either have to listen and change or gradually lose credibility, influence and business. Did I say gradually, again I am in denial 🙂
I know I am bias, but good quality management consultancy can really make a difference. It’s great to see this so clearly articulated. The emphasis is on “good”, because the medioca consultant is what makes people sceptical and in today’s market where money is tight cheaper and poorly qualified people are used as consultants. This is not helping either the organisation or the management consultancy profession.
At the beginning of my consulting-career (15 years ago) I asked an older experienced co-consultant, why companies pay a lot of money for external consulting and not on building own capacities. He said: “they feel better, if we are here and for that kind of brain-wellness they are willing to pay a lot”. Even if I don’t know if he was right or not that time, I avoided to get furthermore lessons from that guy.
I really liked this article. It helped me understand why consultants are hired over asking worker recommendation.
Great article. I look forward to part 2 and hope it has something to say about predictive analytics and how we now have the power to look at the past, present and the future with robust analytics solutions like those found at SAP.
Cheers,
Yes! And companies seeking outside help will benefit from lower, differentiated pricing and more creative consulting offerings from beyond today’s traditional consulting organizations. Can’t wait to read Part Two.
I write from Italy, good article I think in the same way, after 20 years as manager and 10 years as strategic consultant, I think that our role in this complex contest is to help directly to ours customers to build business together and to share the risk and not only bla-bla-bla.
In the next 12 month we are helping a lot of companies in some interazionslization projects together.
I will await next articles
Best regards
Comments on this entry are closed.